Choose 8 min

Should you switch

The product page is a list of capabilities. This bench is the decision around that list: what the README actually counts, who the comparison is for, and the sentence the project uses when it tells you not to treat the alpha as a finished professional tool.

Read the limit before the feature list

What PhotoCraft includes today is the inventory. PhotoCraft, Photoshop, GIMP, and Photopea puts it next to Photoshop, GIMP, and Photopea. What early alpha means is the README status note, in plain language, before you move a client file.

A comparison still needs a file

Install from Which PhotoCraft file to download and try one of your own PSDs with Open and save a PSD without losing the original. A table cannot see the layer that fails in your document.

Questions to answer before you uninstall anything

The useful comparison is a set of jobs, not a score. Do you need a native app on Linux, with no account, and a Photoshop-shaped set of menus? PhotoCraft is built for that try, and it is early alpha. Do you need Photoshop plug-ins, an Extensions menu, or generative tools you already bill for? The README names plug-in compatibility and generative AI as gaps, and the filters page says .8bf plug-ins do not load. Do you need a mature free desktop editor and you can live with different shortcuts? GIMP is that editor. Do you need a layered PSD edit inside an ordinary browser tab on a machine you do not control? Photopea is that web app. PhotoCraft’s own browser build is a zip you host yourself, which is a different arrangement, described in PhotoCraft in the browser.

Do you need a press file delivered this week? The color menus exist, and a deadline is still the wrong trial. Do you need the words in an old PSD to stay editable? They do when they are still a type layer, and they do not when someone rasterized them. That test belongs on a copy, which is Open and save a PSD without losing the original. The inventory you are judging is What PhotoCraft includes today.

What a fair week of copies looks like

Day one is the install from the official release and A first session you can undo on a JPEG you can replace. You should be able to turn the Curves layer off and see the original picture, then export a JPEG and still have a PSD or a .pcraft file. Day two is one of your own documents, duplicated first. Open it, look at the Layers panel, and see whether type still selects, whether a mask is still a mask, and whether the render is something you can use. Save As a new name. Leave the original untouched. Day three, if you print, is a soft proof and a single print from Color, proofing, and print on a copy, not a conversion of the only RGB file.

Stop the week early if the window will not stay open, if a normal PSD is refused for memory, or if a folder batch resized every file to the first file’s size. Those are known open problems, written up on When the window closes or the canvas is slow and Repeat one job on a folder of files. They are a reason to keep the other editor installed, not a reason to download a repackaged installer from a blog. At the end of a quiet week you still have a choice. Familiar menus are a reason to keep the alpha on the machine. They are not a reason to delete the tool that already delivers your work.

The gaps, attached to the page that shows them

Generative fill is a named gap. Select Subject and the Remove tool run on the machine, and the roadmap has described that selection as classical, with the machine-learning backend not started. Treat a mask as a first pass you paint on. Typography depth is a named gap. A caption and a paragraph are the session to try. A layout that depends on rare OpenType features is the session to test, not to promise. Missing tools and unfinished menu items are a named gap. If a command is not where you expect it, Edit, then Search, still finds it by name, including its English name after you switch the interface language.

Plug-in compatibility is a named gap. WebAssembly filters can be installed from the Filter menu. Photoshop plug-ins cannot. Professional handoff is a named gap in the form of the PSD work that is still on the roadmap. What early alpha means is the page that says all of this in the project’s own terms. PhotoCraft, Photoshop, GIMP, and Photopea is the page that turns it into a choice. The install you use for the trial is Which PhotoCraft file to download.