Choose · Compare 10 min

PhotoCraft, Photoshop, GIMP, and Photopea

PhotoCraft is aimed at people who already know a Photoshop-style editor and want that shape without a subscription. It is early alpha. The other tools in this table are not early alpha. That difference is the comparison.

The decision, not a scoreboard

Prices change and editions differ, so this table does not invent a monthly number. Photoshop is the commercial reference and needs an Adobe account. PhotoCraft, GIMP, and Photopea are free to open. Their obligations are different.

A practical comparison, not a benchmark
QuestionPhotoCraftPhotoshopGIMPPhotopea
Cost to openFreeSubscriptionFreeFree, with ads in the web app
LicenseMIT or Apache-2.0ProprietaryGPLProprietary web app
Where it runsmacOS, Windows, Linux, FreeBSD, web buildmacOS, Windows, iPad, webDesktop, including LinuxBrowser
AccountNone for the editorAdobe accountNoneOptional, the app is online
Layered PSDRead and write, test the re-saveNative formatPartialRead and write in the browser
Photoshop-like shortcutsThat is the designYesDifferentClose, in the browser
MaturityEarly alphaProfessional productMatureMature web app
Generative toolsNamed gapPart of the productNot the reason to choose itSome, in the browser

Who should try PhotoCraft this week

Try it if you want a native editor on Linux, a Photoshop-shaped interface, and files you can keep a copy of. The feature inventory is What PhotoCraft includes today. Try the browser build from PhotoCraft in the browser if you only need to know whether the tools feel familiar.

Stay with Photoshop if a job requires plug-ins, a proven handoff, or generative features you already bill for. Stay with GIMP if you want a mature free desktop editor and you do not need Photoshop shortcuts. Stay with Photopea if you need a layered PSD edit in a browser tab and you accept an online app.

Prove it on one file

Install from the official release and run one of your own documents through Open and save a PSD without losing the original. A comparison table that never opened your file is not evidence. The alpha boundary is What early alpha means.

Four jobs, and the tool that fits each one

A Linux machine with no Adobe account, and a wish for menus that feel like Photoshop, is the PhotoCraft trial. Install from Which PhotoCraft file to download, keep GIMP or whatever you use now, and run A first session you can undo on a copy. The license is MIT or Apache-2.0. The status is early alpha. Familiar shortcuts are the design, and unfinished menu items are part of the same design. A shared computer where you cannot install anything is a browser problem. Photopea is the mature web app for a layered PSD in an ordinary tab. PhotoCraft’s web zip is something you host, and app.getartcraft.com is ArtCraft Studio, not that editor. PhotoCraft in the browser separates those three.

A studio that lives on plug-ins, a proven PSD handoff, or generative tools already in the estimate stays on Photoshop. This page does not invent a monthly price, because editions change. A person who wants a mature free desktop editor, and who does not need Photoshop’s shortcuts or a byte-careful PSD round trip, is looking at GIMP. PhotoCraft’s PSD story is real and limited: a published render match, a re-save that is not byte-identical, and a roadmap item about Photoshop opening those saves. The careful version is Open and save a PSD without losing the original. The feature counts you are comparing are What PhotoCraft includes today.

What this table refuses to score

Speed, print-shop acceptance, and font fidelity are not in the table because this site has not measured them on your files. A soft proof on one photograph is Color, proofing, and print. A missing font substitutes, and the interface language will not supply it, which is Edit text in a PSD. An open bug list, memory refusals, a batch resize that copies the first file, an indexed GIF palette that can change, is a maturity fact. It is also a reason the alpha row says early alpha while the other columns say mature. What early alpha means spells out the trials that match that row.

The honest test is one document you duplicated. If the type selects, the mask holds, and the export matches what you needed, you have evidence for that document. If it does not, you still have the original, and you still have the other editor. Familiarity is a reason to keep PhotoCraft installed beside it. Uninstall the other editor only after a week of your own files has gone well, including one PSD round trip and one export you were willing to send. That week is described on What early alpha means.