Choose · Limits 9 min

What early alpha means

The project labels PhotoCraft early alpha and says it plainly: a lot of the surface exists, and it is not yet a Photoshop replacement for daily professional work. This page is that warning, with the gaps they name.

The gaps the README names

The status note points at generative AI, tools that are still missing, depth in typography and professional workflows, and plug-in compatibility. It also says every Photoshop menu item can be wired to a command, and that wiring is not the same as finished behavior.

The roadmap updated 12 November 2026 still treats PSD files that Photoshop will reopen as current work, along with performance and the bug backlog. That is why Open and save a PSD without losing the original starts by copying the file.

Work that fits the alpha

A personal JPEG, a learning file, a Linux machine that had no Photoshop-shaped editor, and a PSD you duplicated are the right trials. A first session you can undo is that trial. A background mask is fair game once you zoom the edge, as in Remove a background on your own machine.

A deadline, a press file, a rare font, or a plug-in action you cannot rewrite are the wrong trials. The print and CMYK menus, if you are only learning them, are Color, proofing, and print. Keep the editor you already trust installed beside it.

Rough edges go back to the project

If a real build crashes or a document opens wrong, the README asks for the operating system, document size, layer count, and a screenshot. File that on GitHub or ask on Discord. A launch problem that is really the wrong installer belongs in When PhotoCraft will not open first. A window that closes, CPU rendering, and the log folder are When the window closes or the canvas is slow.

The comparison, if you are still choosing, is PhotoCraft, Photoshop, GIMP, and Photopea.

Open bugs are part of the alpha, not a footnote

The troubleshooting page, checked 21 November 2026, lists problems that are not fixed yet. A PSD or PSB can be refused for memory, including a report of 0.0 GB free, since 0.21.0, issues 11715 and 11720 and ArtCraft issue 2744. Some Linux drops onto the window fail, issue 11714. A .pcraft file on a NAS can warn even when the save succeeded, issue 11873. A recorded Image Size applies the first file’s size to the rest of a batch, issues 11721 and 11722. The eyedropper can disagree slightly on a CMYK JPEG, ArtCraft issue 2747. Indexed Color saved as GIF can change the palette, issues 11824 and 11826. Some files open in a new window instead of a tab, ArtCraft issue 2725. Full screen can be slow on an Intel MacBook Air, ArtCraft issue 2762. The steps and the log folder are When the window closes or the canvas is slow. The batch case is Repeat one job on a folder of files. The color cases are Color, proofing, and print.

A delivery that depends on one of those behaviors is the wrong trial. A personal file, a duplicated PSD, and a lesson on adjustment layers are the right trial. A first session you can undo is that lesson. The official list is PhotoCraft troubleshooting.

A menu that exists can still be unfinished

The README says much of the Photoshop surface exists in some form, and that wiring a menu item to a command is not finished behavior. Generative AI is named as missing, so Select Subject and the Remove tool should be read as on-device selection and retouching, not as a cloud fill. The roadmap has called the current subject selection classical. Plug-ins you already own as Photoshop .8bf files do not load, and there is no Extensions menu. WebAssembly filters are the add-on path that does exist, under Filter, then Plug-ins. Typography and professional workflow depth are named gaps. A caption is a fair test. A press package with rare fonts and a plug-in action is not. Edit text in a PSD and Filters that preview on the canvas show those two edges.

The roadmap updated 12 November 2026 still lists Photoshop reopening PhotoCraft saves as active work, with performance and the bug backlog beside it. That is why Open and save a PSD without losing the original starts with a duplicate. Keep the previous editor installed. Report a real failure with the operating system, the document size, the layer count, and a screenshot, on the repository or Discord. If the failure is the wrong installer, When PhotoCraft will not open comes before that report. The comparison, if you are choosing rather than reporting, is PhotoCraft, Photoshop, GIMP, and Photopea.